Saturday, August 29, 2009

EPISD: On-line but off target

     The EPISD computer technicians have become the most hated people on Earth. They’re doing some kind of secret experiment that nobody has explained to anyone, for a reason that nobody has explained to anyone, with results that don’t make sense to anyone.
     Thanks to the EPISD technicians, computer labs are not useable, printers don’t print, some computers won’t turn on and many teachers have had their hard drives wiped out with no advance warning, losing some important documents and files forever.
     All the chaos began in the summer. Administrators knew in May that work on almost all the computers would be done and that they would be reformatted. This was passed along to teachers at our campus at a busy end-of-school meeting where almost nobody listens to a word being said and where some people were absent with legitimate excuses.
     At EPHS, I don’t know if any warning was given or not. I know that many teachers were mad when they came back in August and all their saved documents were gone with (they say) no opportunity being given to back them up.
     No memo, e-mail or verbal explanation has been given to teachers concerning what good all of this damage will eventually do, if any. We have pieced together facts and rumors and apparently someone wants a new management system where every computer in the district gets controlled remotely in all aspects from a bunker at the technology office.
     We’ve heard, once it’s all done, nobody will be able to install a program on their own computer or even update any of the existing programs without calling a technician for service. You get a new printer, need to install software (any two-year-old can do it) – you have to call for help. Need to update Acrobat Reader to see a document (this update usually happens almost automatically) – you have to call for help. Supposedly, a technician (or 2, or 3 or 4?) will be connected and be constantly monitoring every computer in the district to make sure it’s being used appropriately. It’s all very Orwellian.
     A few people misuse their computers and some let the students use them for everything EXCEPT academics. We’re throwing the baby out with the bath water here, though. Instead of punishing those who have been irresponsible and making principals supervise technology use more closely, the technology department would rather just make our technology dysfunctional.
     Sadly, we have a school technology department that has no clue about how technology should be integrated into an educational environment. They also have shown no concern about communicating anything to the teachers and students who make up the vast majority of their end users. We had a person hired as an educational technology specialist but his knowledge and training have gone to waste as his role has been relegated – for some illogical reason -- to being just another central office bureaucrat.
     It’s all very frustrating to the students and teachers. We could take our technology and really fly if somebody had the initiative and the knowledge to lead the way. It’s also very sad for the district and the community as a whole that we SHOULD have much more to show for the millions we spend on technology and we’re falling short because of poor leadership.
     Too many of our campus employees have too little training and too little supervision to implement our technology in a smooth manner. But, instead of training them, insisting on better oversight from administrators, and learning to trust everyone, central office would rather stifle the campuses and put obstacles in our way. This type of sorry approach will continue until someone with curriculum experience is put in charge of technology. Such a person would switch the emphasis on technology to teaching and learning and away from record keeping, business transactions, communication and P.R. -- as it presently stands. For the sake of our kids, the existing approach has to change.

6 comments:

Anonymous said...

Every year we are required to fill out a STAR chart which is apparently questionare by the state as to how technology is being used in classroom and accessibility. There is the perfect time for educators to tell the state how backwards we really are in relation to technology. I agree, there are people that misuse the minimum technology we have available. However there are teachers who attempt to integrate technology into our classrooms and that effort will be stifle. FYI even the ability to change the wallpaper has been deactivated on the school computers. They want us to be more technologically advanced yet they are demonstating the opposite.

Anonymous said...

Hilarious! Join the modern world, Juan! Backing up files is common sense. So, because most didnt listen, it's someone else's fault? Thats what happens when someone else owns the system.

Anonymous said...

Someone needs to monitor the campus secretaries. I receive emails that have been sent from secretary to secretary and then on to teachers. Do they not have enough work to do? The worst one is the CATE secretary.

Anonymous said...

I worked for an agency that did exactly the same thing and I had no problem with it since I was using their computer for work. I have no business using the computer for any other purpose other than work. I used to be able to create my own programs on the computer to help me do my work or make it easier just by using the technology that was afforded me by the agency and I don't see why the teachers in the EPISD can't do the same.

Anonymous said...

We were advised at the end of the year to save anything we wanted because everything was going to be lost during the summer when they cleaned out the computers. But now the computers run sooooooooooo slow, it takes forever for the page to load. Should have left them the way they were.

Albino said...

The school where I work has had the same type of policy for years now. We, however, never had freedom to do similar items as you mention, because our school district has always been on top of security issues (Child Internet Protection Act, etc.). If your district receives federal funds (erate, etc.), then these changes are being made to be in compliance with the law. They are, after all, district computers and are to be used for educating children. If you want to do other things, use your home computer. I create all kinds of documents for school at home, because I know they are not going to be erased. Just realize, all of these changes are for security purposes so that children are protected, teachers are protected and the school district is protected. Our district has an Acceptable Usage Policy for computers that we have to sign. This policy has been in existence since 2000-2001.